| YEAR | WINNER | RUNNER-UP |
| 1985 | STEVE HOUCHEN | RICH ADAMS |
| 1986 | GARY HERFEL | JOE NEYER |
| 1987 | BILL BOSS | TOM FULDNER |
| 1988 | GARY SCUDDER | ART GREENE |
| 1989 | BOB SHAWEN | JOE NEYER |
| 1990 | TOM FULDNER | ALAN BROWN |
| 1991 | DON NIEHAUS | STEVE HOUCHEN |
| 1992 | STEVE HOUCHEN | RAY SMALLWOOD |
| 1993 | LANCE LUCAS | RON FREKING |
| 1994 | ROB CLARKE | CURTIS CARPENTER |
| 1995 | STEVE HOUCHEN | GEORGE HIGDON |
| 1996 | LANCE LUCAS | TOM FULDNER |
| 1997 | KEN ROUSE | TOM OLDENDICK DAVE SCHEIDLY |
| 1998 | JEFF FLOYD | ROB CLARKE |
| 1999 | GARY HERFEL | MARK ERLEWINE |
| 2000 | LANCE LUCAS | JIM McCAUSEY |
| 2001 | TOM FULDNER | ROB CLARKE |
| 2002 | ROB CLARKE | MIKE WARD |
| 2003 | LANCE LUCAS | ROB CLARKE |
| 2004 | LANCE LUCAS | MATT BOWLIN |
| 2005 | BEN REISENBECK | BEN REISENBECK |